Difference between revisions of "RCS Platform Comparison"

From RCS Wiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(formatting, switching to refs, shortening lengthy titles and moving excess info to refs, removing search link)
m (remove notes about PCIe extension. reason: OCuLink port on Talos 2 has wrong wiring (custom adapter needed), and PCIe risers don't increase PCIe slot count.)
 
(5 intermediate revisions by one other user not shown)
Line 15: Line 15:
 
| Production || Y || Y || Y || postponed
 
| Production || Y || Y || Y || postponed
 
|-
 
|-
| Reasons to buy || most CPU cores,<br/>max RAM speed,<br/>need >2 PCIe slots<ref group="note">although some of these boards only have two PCIe slots, you can easily expand them using ''PCIe risers'' (some cases have space for these) or using an [https://blog.exxactcorp.com/need-know-oculink-technology/ OCuLink port expander].  Please share your questions and experiences [https://forums.raptorcs.com in the forum].</ref> || Cheaper but still 22 cores || Cheapest,<br/>integrated peripherals,<br/>smaller size || -  
+
| Reasons to buy || most CPU cores,<br/>max RAM speed,<br/>need >2 PCIe slots || Cheaper but still 22 cores || Cheapest,<br/>integrated peripherals,<br/>smaller size || -  
 
|-
 
|-
| Price (USD)<ref group="note">please see online shop for latest prices</ref> || 3,200 || 1,500 || '''1,300''' || -
+
| Price (USD)<ref group="note">please see online shop for latest prices, and be aware that bundles may discount prices if also purchasing CPUs and HSFs. Last updated 2020-07-31.</ref> || 3194.66 || 1502.57 || '''1310.99''' || -
 
|-
 
|-
 
| RYF Certified<ref group="note">Certified by the Free Software Foundation's [https://ryf.fsf.org/vendors/raptor Respects Your Freedom] program</ref> || Y || Y || ? || ?
 
| RYF Certified<ref group="note">Certified by the Free Software Foundation's [https://ryf.fsf.org/vendors/raptor Respects Your Freedom] program</ref> || Y || Y || ? || ?
Line 29: Line 29:
 
| Memory channels || '''8'''<br/>(4 per CPU) || '''4''' || 2 || '''8'''
 
| Memory channels || '''8'''<br/>(4 per CPU) || '''4''' || 2 || '''8'''
 
|-
 
|-
| Memory channels×speed<ref group="note">channels multiplied by maximum speed in MHz</ref> || '''17,064'''<br/>(8,532 ''per CPU'') || 8,532 || 4,800 || ?
+
| Memory channels×speed<ref group="note">channels multiplied by maximum speed in MHz</ref> || '''21 336'''<br/>(10 668 ''per CPU'') || 10 668 || 5334 || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| PCIe 4.0 16x slots || '''3'''<ref group="note" name="t2-1cpu-limit">on Talos II, only 2 PCIe slots are available with a single CPU and all slots are available when 2 CPUs are installed in the board</ref> || 1 || 1 || 4?
+
| PCIe 4.0 16x slots<ref group="note">All x16 slots on Talos II (and Lite) and Blackbird are CAPI 2 capable</ref> || '''3'''<ref group="note" name="t2-1cpu-limit">on Talos II, only 2 PCIe slots are available with a single CPU; two CPUs must be installed for all slots to be available</ref> || 1 || 1 || 4?
 
|-
 
|-
 
| PCIe 4.0 8x slots || '''2'''<ref group="note" name="t2-1cpu-limit"/> || 1 || 1 || ?
 
| PCIe 4.0 8x slots || '''2'''<ref group="note" name="t2-1cpu-limit"/> || 1 || 1 || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| μPCIe slots || '''1''' || '''1''' || 0 || ?
+
| μPCIe ports || '''1''' || 0 || 0 || ?
 
|-
 
|-
 
| Video || VGA || VGA || '''HDMI''' || ?
 
| Video || VGA || VGA || '''HDMI''' || ?
Line 41: Line 41:
 
| USB 3.0 ports || 4 || 4 || 4 || ?
 
| USB 3.0 ports || 4 || 4 || 4 || ?
 
|-
 
|-
| Storage || Optional 4x SAS/SATA || Optional 4x SAS/SATA || 4x SATA || ?
+
| Storage || ''Optional 4x SAS/SATA'' || ''Optional 4x SAS/SATA'' || 4x SATA || ?
 
|}
 
|}
 
<references group="note"/>
 
<references group="note"/>

Latest revision as of 12:19, 31 July 2020

Here is a quick comparison to help people get started with the platform.

Some details have been omitted, this page is intended to give a high-level overview without too much clutter.

Purchasing overview:

  • consider the single CPU board, Talos II Lite as your default option, it offers best performance for a single CPU with all four memory channels loaded
    • if you really need more than 22 CPU cores or more than 2 PCIe slots, consider the full Talos II but be conscious of extra PSU requirements
    • if you really need something compact and potentially portable, consider the Blackbird due to its MicroATX form factor but be aware that you are constrained to only 8 CPU cores (4 threads/core), only 2 memory channels and you need to be careful to choose a case the meets noise and cooling expectations for this board
Feature Talos II Talos II Lite Blackbird Condor
Production Y Y Y postponed
Reasons to buy most CPU cores,
max RAM speed,
need >2 PCIe slots
Cheaper but still 22 cores Cheapest,
integrated peripherals,
smaller size
-
Price (USD)[note 1] 3194.66 1502.57 1310.99 -
RYF Certified[note 2] Y Y ? ?
Size EATX EATX Micro ATX ATX
CPU count 2 1 1 1
CPU max cores 22 22 8 ?
Memory channels 8
(4 per CPU)
4 2 8
Memory channels×speed[note 3] 21 336
(10 668 per CPU)
10 668 5334 ?
PCIe 4.0 16x slots[note 4] 3[note 5] 1 1 4?
PCIe 4.0 8x slots 2[note 5] 1 1 ?
μPCIe ports 1 0 0 ?
Video VGA VGA HDMI ?
USB 3.0 ports 4 4 4 ?
Storage Optional 4x SAS/SATA Optional 4x SAS/SATA 4x SATA ?
  1. please see online shop for latest prices, and be aware that bundles may discount prices if also purchasing CPUs and HSFs. Last updated 2020-07-31.
  2. Certified by the Free Software Foundation's Respects Your Freedom program
  3. channels multiplied by maximum speed in MHz
  4. All x16 slots on Talos II (and Lite) and Blackbird are CAPI 2 capable
  5. 5.0 5.1 on Talos II, only 2 PCIe slots are available with a single CPU; two CPUs must be installed for all slots to be available